Rethinking Motherhood in The Joys of Motherhood: Fulfilment, Burden, and the Question of Choice

Introduction

The Joys of Motherhood by Buchi Emecheta unsettles one of the most powerful cultural myths: that motherhood is a woman’s natural destiny and ultimate fulfilment. Through the life of Nnu Ego, Emecheta examines how maternal devotion can become a site of both emotional meaning and structural exploitation.

Rather than offering a sentimental portrait, the novel interrogates motherhood as a social institution shaped by patriarchy, economic precarity, and colonial transformation. This blog addresses two central questions:

Does the novel ultimately celebrate motherhood or question it?
How does Nnu Ego’s experience compare with representations of motherhood in selected films?

I. Celebration or Critique? The Ambivalence of Motherhood

1. Motherhood as Cultural Fulfilment

At the beginning of the novel, motherhood appears sacred. In Igbo society, a woman’s value is inseparable from her reproductive capacity—especially her ability to bear sons. For Nnu Ego, childlessness is not merely a personal sorrow; it is a social humiliation. Her intense joy at the birth of her first son reflects an internalized belief that motherhood grants legitimacy, continuity, and symbolic immortality.

Here, Emecheta does not mock maternal desire. She acknowledges its emotional depth. Nnu Ego’s happiness is real. Motherhood provides her with belonging and recognition.

Yet this fulfilment is conditional. It depends on society’s approval.

2. Motherhood as Economic and Emotional Labour

As the narrative progresses, fulfilment gives way to exhaustion. In colonial Lagos, survival replaces celebration. Nnu Ego’s life becomes defined by relentless labour—selling goods, managing hunger, and stretching scarce resources to sustain her children.

Motherhood in the novel is not abstract love; it is physical strain and emotional depletion. The expectation that a “good mother” must endure silently transforms care into unpaid, invisible labour.

Two tensions become visible:

Sacrifice vs. Selfhood – Nnu Ego’s identity dissolves into her children’s needs.
Love vs. Obligation – Her devotion is genuine, but it is also socially enforced.

She repeatedly asks, “When will I be free?” This question signals that motherhood, rather than expanding her life, has confined it.

3. Patriarchy and the False Promise of Security

Traditional belief assures women that children—especially sons—will provide security in old age. Nnu Ego sacrifices her youth with the expectation of future gratitude.

But the novel dismantles this promise. Her sons pursue their own ambitions, shaped by colonial education and urban modernity. The communal reciprocity that once sustained mothers collapses.

The tragedy lies not in her children’s independence alone, but in the ideological lie that motherhood guarantees reward. Nnu Ego dies alone, and society canonizes her only after death. The irony is devastating: she receives symbolic honour when material care is no longer possible.

Motherhood here is exposed as:

socially glorified
economically unsupported
emotionally isolating

4. Does Emecheta Reject Motherhood?

It would be simplistic to say the novel rejects motherhood entirely. Emecheta does not deny maternal love; she critiques its institutionalization.

The novel questions:

Compulsory motherhood
Motherhood as sole female identity
Sacrifice as moral obligation

What it demands instead is reciprocity, choice, and recognition. Motherhood, stripped of coercion and economic vulnerability, might indeed contain joy. But under patriarchy and colonial capitalism, it becomes a burden disguised as destiny.

Thus, the novel ultimately questions rather than celebrates motherhood—not by denying its emotional power, but by exposing the structures that exploit it.

II. Motherhood on Screen: Idealization vs. Lived Reality

Visual media often shapes public imagination more powerfully than literature. When we compare Nnu Ego’s experience with certain films, the contrast between representation and reality becomes striking.

1. Sacrificial Motherhood in Mother India

Mother India presents Radha as the archetypal suffering mother. She endures poverty, humiliation, and hardship to uphold moral order. Her sacrifice is framed as heroic and nationally symbolic.

Similarity with Nnu Ego:

Both women endure immense suffering for their children. Both internalize the belief that motherhood requires self-denial.

Key Difference:

Radha is publicly honoured. Her sacrifice becomes epic and redemptive. Nnu Ego, in contrast, dies in obscurity. Her labour is neither mythologized nor materially rewarded.

Cinema elevates sacrifice into glory; Emecheta reveals its loneliness.

2. Selfhood and Motherhood in English Vinglish

English Vinglish portrays Shashi, a homemaker whose family undervalues her. Through learning English, she rebuilds her confidence and identity.

Contrast with Nnu Ego:

Shashi discovers a self beyond motherhood. Her growth does not require abandoning her family; instead, it reshapes familial respect.

Nnu Ego, however, never gains such self-recognition. She lacks the language, education, and social support to imagine herself as an individual subject.

This difference reflects changing definitions of success:

Nnu Ego’s World	Modern Urban Context
Success = Many children	Success = Personal dignity + balance
Identity = Mother only	Identity = Mother + Individual
Sacrifice = Duty	Sacrifice = Negotiable

Modern cinema allows mothers complexity; Emecheta shows what happens when complexity is denied.

3. Emotional Reward in The Pursuit of Happyness

The Pursuit of Happyness centres on a struggling father, yet it reinforces a broader cultural narrative: parental sacrifice leads to eventual success. Hardship becomes meaningful because it culminates in triumph.

In Nnu Ego’s story, no such narrative consolation exists. Her sacrifices do not lead to shared prosperity or emotional closure. The absence of reward is precisely the point.

Popular media often assures audiences that parental suffering is temporary and purposeful. Emecheta refuses this comfort.

III. Modern vs. Traditional Definitions of Success

At the heart of the novel lies a shifting idea of success.

In traditional ideology:

A woman succeeds if her children thrive.
Her individuality is secondary.

In modern discourse:

Success includes autonomy, emotional well-being, and economic security.
Parenthood is one dimension of identity, not its entirety.

Nnu Ego’s tragedy emerges from living at the intersection of two systems: traditional expectations and colonial urban hardship. She bears the weight of both, without the benefits of either.

Conclusion: Beyond the Myth of Joy

The Joys of Motherhood dismantles the sentimental narrative that motherhood is naturally and universally fulfilling. Through Nnu Ego’s life, Emecheta demonstrates how love can coexist with exhaustion, and devotion with erasure.

The novel does not condemn mothers; it condemns the social order that equates womanhood with sacrifice while withholding support, recognition, and autonomy.

If joy exists in the novel, it is fleeting and fragile. What remains enduring is the question it leaves behind:

Can motherhood be truly joyful when it demands the disappearance of the self?

By refusing easy answers, Emecheta compels readers to reconsider not only Nnu Ego’s fate, but the cultural narratives that continue to define women through their capacity to give—often without ever receiving.

Reference

Emecheta, Buchi. The Joys of Motherhood. Heinemann, 1979.

Shinde, Gauri, director. English Vinglish. Hope Productions, 2012. Khan, Mehboob, director. Mother India. Mehboob Productions, 1957. Muccino, Gabriele, director. The Pursuit of Happyness. Columbia Pictures,2006.

Bhargav Makwana

Pages